American Jewelry: Part III

American Jewelry: An Historical Timeline

In a nostalgic wave created by the celebration of the country’s 50th anniversary, Americans began to take pride in previous generations and a mid-eighteenth century revival was born. In this time of relative prosperity, jewelry inherited from grandparents was remodeled and incorporated into modern styling. Blue enamel plaques with diamond accents were popular again. Flowers and contemporary sentiments began to dominate jewelry styling. Designs containing secret messages couched in “the language of flowers” were widely embraced and EtruscanRoman, and Byzantine themes were appearing on the American jewelry scene.

Tapered Drop Earring.

This revival of eighteenth-century styling included some modifications. Earrings were long with detachable pendants. A popular earring pendant during this time was a tapered drop shape with a rounded bottom. Ball drops, hoopsfiligree, and tassels were included in the mix. More open necklines called for larger necklaces and a tapering necklace with a central medallion became the fashion. Lockets with memento compartments were characteristic of this era. A new decorative jewelry element, the reverse crystal intaglio, was invented. This technique took a rock crystal quartz cabochon and featured an intaglio or picture carved on the backside which was colored before mounting.

Victorian Reverse Crystal Intaglio.

Brooches included cameos framed simply or framed ornately, bar brooches with wirework and granulation, and pivoting brooches with a miniature on one side and hairwork on the other. Bracelets were widened with a central bulge decorated by a large monogram or medallion, and for comfort, they were constructed in sections and hinged. Manchettes also briefly enjoyed the spotlight, imitating lacework cuffs in beautifully worked gold.

For men, elaborate vest buttons and shirt studs grew very large. Bold watch chains with multiple dangling keys and revolving seal fobs along with signet rings and gold-topped canes were all the rage. Dress sets comprised of cuff links and shirt studs sometimes included a shirt pin or stickpin and vest buttons.

Hand Carved Civil War Ring, Bone.

Rings became heavier with more decorative elements. Garnetamethystemerald, and diamond continued to be the most popular gems to set in rings. Emblematic rings gained momentum with the U.S. Naval Academy and West Point adopting symbolic rings with a class motto. Bloodstone was a popular gemstone for these rings because of its long history of being worn into battle. The Freemasons continued their new tradition of wearing symbolic jewelry adding rings to their collection. Some Civil War soldiers wore rings that could be used for identification purposes and many soldiers and prisoners of war passed time by carving rings from whatever material was at hand, including bone and wood. Rings carved in this manner often had designs on them to indicate which prison camp the carver was detained in. With the invention of die striking machinery, mass production of rings became possible, changing the way jewelry was made forever.

Tiffany & Co. Watch with Patek Philippe Movement

Tiffany & Co., Patek Philippe Watch, Reverse
c. 1868.

Watch manufacturing in America gained momentum in the 1830s with new machinery for tooling the necessary parts being a key component in the industry’s success. The drive to produce American made watches led to many inventions and patents for making the necessary precision elements, further fueling the rapidly growing industrialization of the United States. An entire industry grew up around American watchmaking including jewelers specializing in watch cases, engravers, gem cutters and chain makers, all necessary in feeding the growing industry. Nevertheless, Swiss watches were still considered the standard and retailers such as Tiffany began to import Patek Philippe movements in 1847 to put in their watches.

In 1828 a tariff was imposed on the importation of manufactured goods. In an effort to retain their profits, jewelers switched to the importation of unmounted diamonds and began manufacturing their own jewelry to set them in. The demand for diamond jewelry grew exponentially as more and more people had the means to afford it. Meanwhile, in France, with the rise of the second republic and the attendant revolutionary fervor, there was a glut of diamonds on the market, including the French Crown Jewels. Tiffany’s purchasing agent over there took full advantage of the situation and was able to acquire diamond goods at a fraction of their value. The name Tiffany became synonymous with “The King of Diamonds”1and their Paris branch set them apart from the rest of the New York jewelry trade.

Tiffany & Co. 128.54 Carat Diamond c.1879.

In 1859 a “Diamond Wedding” took place in New York between Frances Amelia Bartlett and the wealthy Don Esteban Santa Cruz de Oviedo (a Cuban citizen). The bride received a magnificent parure created by Tiffany & Co. composed of pearls and diamonds unlike anything previously seen outside of the courts of Europe. Ball, Black & Co. also created elaborate jewels for the bridal trousseau. The total value of all the jewelry created by the two firms for the bride was estimated at $90,000. The entire affair was a tribute to the American jewelry firms who created these amazing jewels and the widespread publicity of the event fueled a bridal jewelry revolution in America.


Henry D. Morse of Boston, a trained silversmith, became interested in diamonds. With the influx of diamonds from S. Africa, Morse partnered with importer B.S. Pray and together they established the first diamond cutting company in the United States. In their early days they employed skilled diamond cutters from Antwerp who maintained a deep secrecy surrounding their diamond cutting methods. Eventually though, Morse gleaned enough knowledge from his employees to be able to begin experimenting with diamond cutting himself. Morse then covertly trained American men and women in the art and skill of diamond fashioning and the American diamond cutting industry was thus born. With his newly acquired skill and the vast quantity of diamonds from South Africa, Morse succeeded in propelling the field of diamond cutting to new heights. Morse’s foreman, Charles Field invented a diamond bruting machine, the double lathe, which used one diamond to cut another, and enabled the first truly round cut diamonds.

European-Cut Diamond.

Prior to this invention “round” diamonds had a squarish outline. Morse, continually conducting research with regard to diamond’s optical properties, eventually concluded that the diamond’s proportions should be changed so as to raise the girdle to one-third of the way below the table facet and two-thirds of the way above the pavilion, bringing out a brilliance in diamonds heretofore unseen. This produced the first diamond with a truly round outline and good optical proportions; the “American cut” was born. Morse’s work with diamond proportions was later popularized by Marcel Tolkowsky leading to the so called “ideal-cut” diamond. Field’s invention and Morse’s diamond proportions were adopted in Europe and the “European-cut” was born, a name that lives on today.

Open Back Diamond Setting.

Advances in diamond cutting were augmented by equally radical advances in diamond setting. Open backed settings, which increased the diamond’s brilliance by allowing light to enter the stone from all angles, were gaining popularity. This new openness, created by cutting the back of a collet, evolved into prong settings which in turn added even more fire and brilliance to the gems. A machine that could raise prongs by a stamping process soon followed, making gem-set jewelry even more affordable. By 1875 almost no diamond jewelry was being imported; American jewelers had turned the tide.

Colored gems continued to be prized but the list expanded to include rubies and opals. In 1833 Palmer & Clapp made the first “regard” rings by utilizing different colored gems to spell out secret sentiments. Engagement rings began to feature rubies and emeralds. The discovery of high-quality opals in Australia in 1849 and Queen Victoria’s love of the gem created a European fashion frenzy for the gem which inevitably found its way to America. Opals were paired with rubies and emeralds and eventually with diamonds as well. Large garnets were being cut en cabochon and this new style helped to retain garnet’s earlier popularity. Bohemian garnet jewelry enjoyed a resurgence with a look that harkened back to the early days of American independence. Amethyst in very large sizes also staked its claim among the popular gemstones. Turquoise, set in gold and usually combined with other gems, was a new and exciting fashion trend. It was believed that the combination of turquoise and ruby signified love. Turquoise with pearls created another intriguing and popular combination.

Antique Opal Earrings.

Victorian Regard Ring.

Turquoise, Pearl and Gold Earrings.

Etruscan Revival Opal and Pearl Brooch.

Exciting new styles included jewelry inspired by ancient Egypt and Etruscan revival jewelry based on the artifacts recovered from ancient Etruscan burial sites. Etruscan Revival’s distinctive decorative elements include the extensive use of granulation and filigree. Fortunato Pio Castellani rediscovered the technique for granulation after studying this newly recovered ancient jewelry. Castellani’s work became very fashionable in Europe and his jewelry, purchased by wealthy tourists, spread the Etruscan revival style throughout the world. Americans embraced the style and American jewelry makers began to produce their own versions, lending it a certain cache by pretending to import it from Europe.

The discovery of new, more abundant deposits of freshwater pearls in America further fueled the desire for elaborately woven pearl designs. Slices of mother-of-pearl continued to serve as the template and infrastructure for these intricate designs although they now had the addition of gold for strength. The natural themes so prevalent during this period were evident as well in the new pearl designs. Gone were colored gemstones mixed with pearls as all white compositions were desired and deemed flattering to all who wore them. These magnificent creations became a necessity for every bride. Tiffany created a seed pearl set that was purchased by Abraham Lincoln and worn by Mrs. Lincoln to the Inauguration. This old-style European design was now an American tradition.

Bow Brooch with American Pearl Pendant.

Hair jewelry continued to be popular for remembrance and friendship, with the designs becoming more and more elaborate, woven and puffed into amazing forms and shapes. With the onset of Civil War, this form of memento jewelry became more popular than ever. Along with hair jewelry, portrait miniatures became larger, often too large to even be worn. This art form died an abrupt death however in 1839 with the invention of the daguerreotype. Ready-made brooches and pendants appeared in the shops waiting only for the customer to provide the daguerreotype of the loved one to complete the piece. Sometimes the miniaturist’s skill was still called for in applying color to the daguerreotype portraits. These Civil War daguerreotypes were often combined with hair jewelry to create a complete remembrance of someone gone to war or one who would never return.

Locket with Hair Memento.

Locket with Daguerreotype.

In Europe a great many new materials were being used in what is now referred to as “tourist” jewelry. Travelers returning from Europe brought tortoise shell souvenirs home and demand grew. Jewelers began to import these new jewelry items to satisfy the growing desire for them in the United States. American jewelers imported hawk’s bill turtle shells in order to carve their own hair combs, chains, brooches, etc. American ingenuity and newly invented machinery allowed American designers the freedom to reinvent this tortoise shell jewelry in the “American taste”. Bold pique designs appeared, much grander than any produced in Europe. Along with the genuine come the imitations and vulcanitehorn and celluloid begun to appear on the American market circa 1850. As hairstyles became less complex though, the booming hair comb business died out.

Pique Brooch – Tortoise Shell and Mixed Metals.

Tortoise Shell Jewelry Suite.

Tortoise Shell Jewelry Suite.

Tortoise Shell Locket and Chain.

Black and White Onyx Cameo.

A revival of the use of cameos in American jewelry coincided with a rise in the number of trained sculptors with the necessary skills to produce these fine carvings. As these artisans could not readily sell their large, highly-priced sculptures, they created smaller more manageable carvings in the form of cameos that were affordable and purchased by a much wider audience. Portrait cameos helped fill the gap between miniature painting, which was going out of style, and photographic portraits which were still in their infancy. Cameos could be produced using a variety of shell materials as well as hardstone. In America, black onyx backgrounds with white carvings were the most desired. The Centennial Exhibition in Philadelphia in 1876 featured vast displays of cameos from around the world, including those carved by traditional Italian and German designers, which were displayed alongside those made in America. New materials used for carving cameos included lavacoral, and imitations such as glass and celluloid.

Roman Micromosaic Depicting an Ancient Temple.

A long held Roman tradition of creating mosaics with classical themes, made from tiny pieces of glass called tesserae, was finding its way to America. Around 1840 mosaic jewelry began to appear in American portraits. Enterprising jewelers, including Tiffany, took advantage of the popularity of these tourist pieces and began importing these miniature works of art. Imported mosaics set by American jewelers were far superior to any tourist jewelry items available in Rome. At the 1876 Philadelphia Centennial Exhibition, a portrait of Abraham Lincoln done in a micromosaic further increased the American interest in this medium.

Floral Florentine Pietra Dura Brooch.

Florentine style mosaics were also popular and adapted readily to the American taste. These mosaics, referred to as pietra dura, were composed of larger carved gemstones arranged jigsaw puzzle style within black marble. Malachite and lapis lazuli, because of their vivid color, were particularly favored in these pieces. Floral motifs composed of a myriad of gemstones, from simple to elaborate, were the most prolific theme. These mosaics were deemed acceptable daytime wear for a proper lady, thereby increasing their popularity. In addition, Florentine mosaics were not only created for use in jewelry, but also for use as table tops and other decorative objects.

Jewelry that featured souvenirs of big game hunting was being worn by women in England. The look proved popular enough that Tiffany began to design jewelry that featured tiger claws with intricate mountings. “The claws were turned into a pleasing and unferocious ornament.”2 Another material derived from hunting was ivory and, while widely popular in Europe, in America the less expensive imitations such as bone and celluloid were more likely to be worn. Another substitute for ivory was a clay-like material called Meershaum which was carved into cameos and other decorative objects.

Tiger Claw and Gold Filigree Earrings.

Black Onyx Mourning Earrings, Civil War Era.

Banded Agate Earrings.

Scottish Agate Brooch.

Victoria’s long period of mourning had its effect on American jewelry as well. While mourning conventions were prevalent in the United States, they were not typically as severe as those imposed by Queen Victoria’s mourning of Prince Albert. Nevertheless, jewelry designed to be worn during mourning, including items made from jet and black onyx, along with Scottish pebble jewelry found its way into American fashion. As American jewelers began to produce their own versions they discovered that they had the necessary natural resources close at hand. Banded agatecarnelian, and other similar stones were all available, and jet from Colorado, as fine as any found in Whitby, was being sent to England for carving. When Victoria’s mourning finally lifted in 1887, jet and all its imitations soon disappeared from fashion.

Gold and silver were still the metals of choice for fine jewelry making although gold was gaining over silver as the preferred metal for stone setting. Alloys of various colors of gold came on the scene and designs began to incorporate multiple colors of gold. New techniques for finishing as well as patterning and texturing on gold, added new dimension to jewelry design. Granulation, Florentine finishes, matte surfacing, (including a process that involved a scratch brush on a lathe lubricated with beer) and gilding were among the new gold finishing techniques.

A Pair of Victorian Tricolor Gold Bird Motif Earrings.

Gold-in-Quartz Watch Fob.

Multi-Color Gold Earrings.

“Diggers” Stickpin.

The California gold rush provided not only raw materials, in the form of gold bars assayed and shipped directly from California to jewelers in New York and Newark, it also provided inspiration for jewelry design. Digger’s brooches, stickpins, vest buttons, rings and other items, all with gold nuggets, were popular examples of gold rush jewelry. A San Francisco firm located on Sutter Street, called the California Jewelry Co., became known for their fine “California” style jewelry. In the hopes that they could provide not only tourist souvenirs of a California visit, they attempted to provide the west coast with every kind of jewelry necessity. They patented buckle designs and specialized in jewelry utilizing the local gold-in-quartz. This gold-in-quartz from the California gold fields was inlaid in watch chains, match boxes, pins, buckles, locketspendants, rings and other objects of truly American jewelry design.

Timeline: Part III

Fletcher and Gardiner
Philadelphia PA
  • Known for their high-quality presentation pieces.
  • Benjamin Shreve
    Saco ME
    Later New York
  • Many partnerships from 1853 - 1869

  • Small sentimental jewelry.
  • Louis Jaccard
    St. Louis MO
  • Watches and sentimental jewelry.
  • Caldwell & Bennett
    J. E. Caldwell and James M. Bennett
    1868 renamed J.E. Caldwell Philadelphia PA
  • Chosen by Godey’s Lady’s Book to create the jewelry sold to subscribers through the magazine.
  • Baily & Co.
    Philadelphia PA
  • Baily & Co. was the first American firm to use the higher British standard of .925 silver instead of the lower .900.
  • Elijah Peacock
    Charles Peacock

    (1838-1903) Chicago IL
    Peacock, Charles and Elijah
  • 1837 – Lake Street

  • Randolph & Franklin (destroyed in Chicago fire - 1871)

  • West Madison St.

  • Washington St.

  • 101 S. State Street - today

  • Clocks, watches small jewelry, chains, lockets and wedding rings.
  • Charles Tiffany
    Tiffany, Young & Ellis
    Tiffany & John P. Young

    259 Broadway NY
    Tiffany and Co.
    Tiffany and Co.

    • 1841: J.L. Ellis joined the firm Young went to Europe to explore possibilities.

    • 1853: Young & Ellis retired and the firm became Tiffany & Co.

    • Decorative objects for the home.

    • German costume jewelry.

    • Paste from Paris (Palais Royal).

    • Genuine Jewelry from Paris & London.

    • 1848 Gold & Diamond jewelry of their own design.

    • John Young in Paris took advantage of the fall of Louis Philippe and purchased the court’s jewelry and enough diamonds to keep the firm going for years to come.

    • Charles Tiffany became known as the king of diamonds.

    Ball, Black & Company
    New York, NY
    Ball Black & Company
    Ball Black & Company
  • One of the firms involved in the “Diamond Wedding” specializing in rare gems.

  • Charles Goodyear1839
  • Discovery of the process of vulcanizing rubber. This would lead to the ability to create two part molds for the jewelry industry.

  • J. Gorham & Son
    Gorham Manufacturing
  • Manufactured household items in silver.

  • Alling & Co.
    Newark NJ
  • Manufactrured gold jewelry for J.E. Caldwell, M.W. Galt, C.D. Peacock, Baily, Banks & Biddle, Tiffany & Co. and many others.
  • Carter, Gough & Co.
    Newark NJ
    Carter, Gough & Co.
  • One of the largest jewelry producing factories in the world.

  • 1850s They were the first to use a steam engine to produce jewelry.
  • Riker & Tay
    Riker Brothers

    Newark NJ
    Riker Bros
  • Patented processes for surface ornamentation of jewelry and an improved sash fastener. Manufactured gold fob, chains and fobs and were an early manufacturer of Masonic jewelry. They also worked in plique à jour enamel.
  • Gold Rush
    Sutter's Mill California
  • Gold brought prospectors and gold seekers from all over the world.

  • Jones, Ball & Poor
    Boston MA
    Jones, Ball & Poor
  • Most advanced jewelry store in the United States.

  • Separate retail and wholesale entrances.

  • Vault provided for use by customers to store their goods.

  • Workshop below street level.

  • 1852 Benjamin Shreve joined

  • 1869 Charles H. Crump joined and Shreve, Crump and Low was formed.
  • Herman Marcus
    New York NY
  • Immigrated from Dresdin and worked for Ball Black & Co. and Tiffany.

  • 1864 Joined Theodore B. Starr.

  • Connoisseur of Cameos.
  • Trade Treaty with China1853
  • Trade opened up with China creating many opportunities.

  • Tiffany & Co.
    Moved to 550 Broadway NY
    Tiffany and Co.
  • Partners Young & Ellis Retired and the firm became Tiffany & Co.

  • 1856 - pieces from a Hartford Connecticut historic oak tree, felled in a storm, were used by Tiffany to make patriotic carvings for jewelry.

  • 1858 - Tiffany bought the last, unused 20 miles of the transatlantic cable and created souvenir jewelry.

  • Built a new location at Broadway and 15th with workshops and retail space.

  • Paris Branch.

  • London Branch.

  • Office and Watch Manufacturing in Geneva, Switzerland.

  • Incorporated as a Full fledged manufacturer.

  • Until 1880 Sole distribution of Patek Philippe & Co. in USA.

  • During the Civil War they provided Swords, uniform laces, epaulettes, ornaments and medals and badges, caps, rifles and shoes. The profits enabled Tiffany & Co. to return to making jewelry and silverware after the war as a major player.
  • George Shreve
    Apprentice to Benjamin
    Shreve and Co.
  • George and brother Samuel sailed for the California gold rush in 1852. Established a jewelry business upon arrival. After Samuel’s death George Shreve went on to develop Shreve & Co. into the finest jewelry establishment in the west.

  • Silver and decorative items for the home as well as jewelry.
  • 16 Watchcase Companies
    Philadelphia PA
  • American watch case manufacturing for both imported Swiss works and American made watches.

  • Silver Discoveries in America1859
  • Colorado

  • Comstock Lode NV

  • Met the demands of American silver manufacturers and allowed them to prosper.
  • Crosby & Morse
    Samuel T. Crosby
    Henry D. Morse
    Boston MA
  • Crosby was a manufacturing jewelry who also imported globally.

  • Morse was a noted gem cutter.

  • This partnership afforded their customers a wider variety of gem materials than any other store in the area.

  • Carried Byzantine mosaics and Etruscan revival jewelry.
  • Gump’s
    San Francisco CA
  • Evolved from selling decorative objects to the newly rich in SF to exotic items from the East including jade jewelry.
  • Theodore B. Starr
    Starr & Marcus
    John Street NY
    Starr, Theodore B.
    Starr, Theodore B.
  • Partnered with Herman Marcus.
  • Gorham Manufacturing Company
  • Using steam power they revolutionized silver production in America.

  • Mass produced silverware.
  • Larter & Sons
    John Street NY
    Newark NJ
    Larter & Sons
  • Larter & Sons specialized in Gentleman’s jewelry.

  • 1890s they patented a spring link for their sleeve link buttons and in 1890 they patented a spring back stud.
  • Krementz & Co.
    Newark NJ
  • Inventors of the one-piece collar button, bean-and-post cuff button and bodkin clutch vest buttons.

  • They became the preeminent collar button producer world wide.

  • They developed a technique for fusing gold onto base metal for collar buttons and other gentleman’s jewelry.
  • Paris Exposition
    Paris, France
  • Tiffany won first prize for its silverware – the first ever for the United States.
  • Greenleaf & Crosby
    Jacksonville FL
  • Florida souvenirs and jewelry.

  • 1887 St. Augustine - Alacazar.

  • 1895 Palm Beach – Royal Poinciana Hotel.

  • 1900 Miami – Breakers & Royal Hotel.
  • J.E. Caldwell Co.
    Chestnut Street Philadelphia PA
    Caldwell, J.E.
    Caldwell, J.E.
  • Reorganized as J.E. Caldwell Co.
  • William Shreve
  • Joined Shreve & Co. in 1858.

  • Went east to join the Ninth New York Militia and later the Second United States Sharp Shooters during the Civil War.
  • Unger Brothers
    Newark NJ
    Unger Bros.
  • They started out manufacturing gold jewelry but switched to silverware and silver jewelry. In 1910 they became famous for their Art Nouveau designs. 1916 they made toilet articles.
  • Cortlandt W. Starr
    Black, Star & Frost
    1876 B, S & F moved to 251 Fifth Ave. New York NY
    Black Starr and Frost
  • Distinguished during the Civil War, turned jewelry maker.

  • Small versions of European style diamond jewelry items, bows, flowers, leaves, etc.
  • Jewelers’ Circular and Horological Review
    New York NY
  • Published jewelry news throughout the U.S.
  • John Ruskin & Charles Eliot Norton
    Boston MA
  •  First organization offering classes and lectures on the crafts.
  • More American Jewelry Articles



    • Dietz, Ulysses Grant; Joselit, Jenna Weissma; Smead, Kevin J.; and Zapata, Janet. The Glitter & the Gold: Fashioning America’s Jewelry, Newark NJ: The Newark Museum, 1997.
    • Fales, Marthy Gandy. Jewelry in America 1600-1900: Woodbridge, Suffolk England: Antique Collectors’ Club, 1995.
    • Price, Judith. Masterpieces of American Jewelry. Philadelphia: Running Press, 2004.
    • Proddow, Penny and Healy, Debra. American Jewelry: Glamour and Tradition: New York NY: Rizzoli, 1987.
    • Romero, Christie. Warmans Jewelry: Radnor PA: Wallace-Homestead Book Company, 1995.
    • “The Pioneer Lapidary: Death of H.D. Morse the Well Known Dealer in Diamonds.” New York Times, January 4, 1888.


    1. Fales, p. 194
    2. Fales, p. 260